Common Pronoun Usage Errors Apr 27, 2013
Here are three common pronoun mistakes that every student should look for in their writing.
A person, place, thing, or idea (sister, park, table, freedom, etc.)
A word that replaces a noun (I, she, he, they, we, it, etc.)
The thing in a sentence that's performing the action. In the sentences "I walked to school" and "Jessica ate cake," the subjects I and Jessica are performing the action.
The thing in a sentence that receives the action of a verb or preposition. In the sentences "My brother kicked the ball" and "I passed the book to Abby," the ball and Abby are objects receiving the action of the sentence.
1. Using a plural pronoun for a singular noun
If a writer replaces a singular noun with a plural pronoun, they have made a mistake.
This is a common problem for professional writers
as well as students, and as a student you shouldn't feel too bad if it crops up in your papers every now and again. That's because this mistake isn't really the writers fault-instead, it's a problem with the English language
itself. Unlike many other languages, English doesn't have a gender-neutral pronoun, that is, a pronoun that you can use to refer to a person without indicating their gender. You can say that "he
did something" or "she
said that," but there's no word to indicate that you're talking about someone who's not specifically male or female. (While the pronoun it
is gender neutral, it's only used to refer to things, not people.)
The lack of a gender-neutral pronoun can cause problems for writers when they want to replace a gender-neutral, singular noun like "student" or "guest" with a pronoun. Writers have several options, none of which sound particularly good. To be technically correct, you can use "he/his" or "she/her."
Each student needs to bring his own lunch.
If a guest wants to order room service, she needs to have cash.
As you might have noticed, this construction implies that the student or guest is necessarily male or female, which is why most style guides recommend using "he or she" or "his or her."
Each student needs to bring his or her own lunch.
If a guest wants to order room service, he or she needs to have cash.
In order to avoid this awkward construction, many writers have picked up the habit of using "they" in place of "he or she." The problem with this is that the noun being replaced is singular, so the use of "they/their" is technically incorrect. However, it is usually accepted in informal writing.
Each student needs to bring their own lunch.
If a guest wants to order room service, they need to have cash.
Another way to get around the awkward "he or she" construction is to simply make your singular noun plural. This won't always work, but in many instances it can be a good way to avoid mistakes or clunky writing.
Students need to bring their own lunches.
If guests want to order room service, they need to have cash.
2. Misusing subject and object pronouns
Between you and I, I find it very annoying when subject pronouns are misused.
Pronouns can cause more problems when writers need to decide between the subject and object cases. Remember, a subject is a noun that's performing the action of a sentence, and an object is a noun that receives that action. Because pronouns replace nouns, they come in two different flavors: subject pronouns (I, you, he, she, it, we, and they) and object pronouns (me, you, him, her, it, us, and them). If the noun you're replacing is a subject, it's replaced with a subject pronoun, and if it's an object it's replaced by an object pronoun.
We are going to the game tonight. (We are performing an action.)
My parents gave us new coats for winter. (The jackets are being given to us.)
You'll get your dessert after me. (Me is part of a prepositional phrase, which also takes an object pronoun.)
There are several ways these can get mixed up, but the most common mistake is mixing object and subject pronouns together in the same phrase, often with a preposition. This is usually done because students think it sounds more formal or correct.
Between you and I, this dinner just isn't very good.
They gave the highest grades to my friend and I.
In both these examples, the "I" is part of a prepositional phrase, which means the object pronoun should be used instead.
Between you and me, this dinner just isn't very good.
They gave the highest grades to my friend and me.
3. Myself, himself, and herself
Because she gave the money to myself, I can decide what to do with it.
The incorrect use of the reflexive pronouns (myself, himself, herself, yourself, itself, ourselves, themselves) is another mistake that often comes about because students are trying to sound proper or formal. Like the use of "between you and I," the practice of adding "myself" or "himself" has crept into common usage, but there are in fact only a few narrow circumstances in which it's ok to use reflexive pronouns.
The first, and main, use of reflexive pronouns is to take the place of the object of a sentence when it's the same as the subject.
Elizabeth injured Elizabeth on the trampoline
becomesElizabeth injured herself on the trampoline.
I write poetry only for me.
becomesI write poetry only for myself.
Sometimes reflexive pronouns can be used to add emphasis. You should be aware, though, while this is technically correct, it's not a construction commonly used in academic or formal writing.
I myself have never read that particular book.
back to all posts
Note that the sentence still makes sense without the reflexive pronoun (I have never read that particular book). If you find places if your academic writing
where removing the reflexive pronoun leaves behind a sentence that still makes sense, then you should take it out.
By Kevin Demlon
. Kevin writes helpful articles to share his knowledge with students in need. He enjoys writing articles on new subjects and does his best to create each post showing writing tips in a clear way.